Saint Augustine
Mayday Handcrafted Ice Cream

Mayday Handcrafted Ice Cream

Sweets & Treats in St. Augustine

4.9 1,804 Google reviews

+1 904 792 98 60100 St George St # J, St. Augustine, Florida 32084 · Historic District

Mayday Handcrafted Ice CreamMayday Handcrafted Ice Cream, photo 2Mayday Handcrafted Ice Cream, photo 3Mayday Handcrafted Ice Cream, photo 4

Where to find them

100 St George St # J, St. Augustine, Florida 32084

Free newsletter

More of St. Augustine in your inbox

Local news, new businesses and what's on from COAST & HOME | First Coast, once a week.

Get directionsOpen in Maps

About

Mayday Ice Cream is your small-batch, artisan ice cream destination in Florida. We handcraft innovative and authentic flavors, bake our own waffle cones, and hand make our own sprinkles. We are spreading joy from St. Augustine to Jacksonville, Tampa, and beyond. Online pints ship anywhere in the continental U.S., and we offer fun seasonal treats, catering, and in-store events!

Amenities

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible seating

What people say

5 out of 5 stars

“Great ice cream. The lactose free options are also solid. Our family's favorite local place for a cold treat.”
Google review · Oct 2026

5 out of 5 stars

“Very kind, very knowledgeable, very helpful young lady . Her name was Rose . The ice cream and the cookies are delicious. Thank you”
Google review · Oct 2026

5 out of 5 stars

“I will definitely be going back. Rose made me a 10/10 sundae and I am eager to try more flavors. The cookie sample I tried was perfection as well.”
Google review · Oct 2026

Hours

Wednesday
12 to 10 PM
Thursday
12 to 10 PM
Friday
12 to 11 PM
Saturday
12 to 11 PM
Sunday
12 to 10 PM
Monday
12 to 10 PM
Tuesday
12 to 10 PM

More Sweets & Treats in Saint Augustine

Tedi's Ice Cream Ice cream shop
Located on St. George Street in the heart of St. Augustine’s Historic District, Tedi’s Ice Cream is a family-run business and the oldest ice cream shop in the city. Proudly “scooping since ’66,” Tedi’s has been serving locals and visitors for generations. The shop features delicious Florida-made ice cream, fresh hand-squeezed lemonade, and waffle cones made daily. Guests can also enjoy coffee, lattes, chocolates, and a variety of sweet treats. Whether taking a break from sightseeing or cooling off on a warm Florida day, Tedi’s offers a welcoming taste of St. Augustine history.
The Hyppo Gourmet Ice Pops Ice cream shop
The Hyppo makes handcrafted gourmet ice pops using fresh, never-frozen fruit and thoughtfully selected, quality ingredients. Since 2010, we’ve created hundreds of unique flavor combinations, from refreshing fruit-forward favorites to unexpected pairings like Strawberry Basil and Mango Habanero. Visit one of our pop shops, find us through retailers and partners, or order online. Fresh fruit, bold flavors, and always something new to discover.
Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge Ice cream shop
Kilwins is renowned for its hand-crafted chocolates, creamy fudge, caramel apples, brittle, and super-premium ice cream, all made with the finest ingredients. Kilwins has been making people happy since 1947, providing customers with warm, friendly service and a nostalgic confectionery experience. Customers can enjoy watching fudge being paddled on a marble table and caramel cooking in a copper kettle, all in an open kitchen setting.. Kilwins is truly "Sweet in every Sense since 1947."
Castillo Ice Cream and coffee Ice cream shop
We are a family owned and ran ice cream and coffee shop. Espresso, lattes, cappuccino, Frappuccino, iced lattes, milkshakes, root beer floats and more. We also have sundaes and banana splits. We have 42 flavors of ice cream to choose from. Indoor and outdoor seating, with a great view of the Castillo de San Marco. Right next to trolley stop number 5
The Sweet Spot Ice cream shop
The Sweet Spot is a creamery Serving the best ice cream and know with our Specials "SuperShakes"
Peace Pie Ice cream shop
Peace Pie Aviles will be closed until October 2nd. Come see us during First Friday! The Patented Ice Cream Sandwich with a Layer of Pie Filling! Ice cream scoops on our delicious crunchy shortbread cookies are topped with layers of our signature pie fillings and toppings.
The St. Augustine Scoop Ice cream shop
Local Ice Cream Shop featuring premium ice cream, milkshakes and the coolest St. Augustine Swag! Hip, casual atmosphere easily walkable, bike ridable, parking and the best prices in town. Find a flew blocks north of downtown in the "Uptown" neighborhood. Also find us on Instagram @thestascoop
Peace & Cream Ice cream shop
Whole fruit smoothies, açai & pitaya bowls, Italian ice, and soft serve ice cream treats. Served oceanfront beside ‘Ragga Surf Cafe’ at San Sebastian Marina. Parked beside Ragga Surf Cafe's waterfront location, you'll find a 1977 mint green Airstream. A joy-filled shop that will delight you with delicious flavors, a little nostalgia, & treats for everyone. Featuring handcrafted menu items: SMOOTHIES • ACAI & PITAYA BOWLS • ITALIAN ICE • SOFT SERVE • DELICIOUS SUNDAES • FROZEN TREATS

Is this your business? Free, takes two minutes.

COAST & HOME | First Coast

© 2026 COAST & HOME | First Coast.

There’s more to Saint Augustine than you’ve discovered—and your next favorite is waiting. Coast & Home First Coast brings you tempting bites, can’t-miss events, neighborhood gems, and the stories behind our local people and businesses. Each edition opens another door to life that's close to home, with fresh finds and more reasons to get out, connect with friends, and explore what the First Coast has to offer. Subscribe so you won't miss out, and see what unfolds next.

© 2026 COAST & HOME | First Coast.