Saint Augustine
Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company

Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company

Sweets & Treats in St. Augustine

4.5 618 Google reviews

+1 904 547 29 616 Cordova St, St. Augustine, Florida 32084 · Historic District

Bar Harbor Cheesecake CompanyBar Harbor Cheesecake Company, photo 2Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company, photo 3Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company, photo 4

Where to find them

6 Cordova St, St. Augustine, Florida 32084

Free newsletter

More of St. Augustine in your inbox

Local news, new businesses and what's on from COAST & HOME | First Coast, once a week.

Get directionsOpen in Maps

About

Indulge in velvety cheesecakes, handcrafted with exquisite precision at Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company. Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine's historic streets, this dessert haven tantalizes taste buds as a dessert restaurant, restaurant, wine store, and chocolate shop all rolled into one. With each luscious bite, savor the passion and artistry poured into every slice, paired perfectly with the right wine or a delightful hot chocolate. Whether you're seeking an intimate dinner, a sweet treat, or just a glass of wine, Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company promises a culinary experience that will linger in your memory forever.

Amenities

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating

What people say

5 out of 5 stars

“Before you look at this review and think, whoa it has 5 stars, let's just go... let me be clear. This is 5 stars for me, it may not be your cup of tea and complimentary pineapple. This place has an eccentric nature, there's a bit of whimsy and magic in the walls. Respect that if you visit here. Don't come in here expecting ordinary, come here expecting to be surprised. Come in here with an open mind and with gratitude. Come in with appreciation for the art and artistry of not just what you're eating but the surroundings you are in as well. It's an epicurean delight and it is not for everyone. This is a special place. Amd for those of us that love it, we kindly ask you to respect it in kind. There's plenty of places to take some negative energy and a bad attitude. This isn't it. This is a place to visit when you're feeling a bit mischievous. When you want to not pay attention to calories and don't have the patience for the weights and troubles of outside. This is a space for culinary bliss. Walk on the wild side, try something new. Just make sure you're chill before you walk in, this place doesn't have a lot of room and the negativity won't fit through the door!”
Google review · Oct 2026

4 out of 5 stars

“A small but mighty dessert place, but wait, there's more. They also have light bites, wine, tea......”
Google review · Sep 2026

5 out of 5 stars

“Delicious cheesecake for a person who doesn't like cheesecake.”
Google review · Sep 2026

Hours

Wednesday
11:11 AM to 11:11 PM
Thursday
11:11 AM to 11:11 PM
Friday
11:11 AM to 11:11 PM
Saturday
11:11 AM to 11:11 PM
Sunday
11:11 AM to 11:11 PM
Monday
11:11 AM to 11:11 PM
Tuesday
11:11 AM to 11:11 PM

More Sweets & Treats in Saint Augustine

Cookie Crush by Mayday Dessert restaurant
Cookie Crush by Mayday brings warm, freshly-baked cookies together with Mayday’s handcrafted ice cream. Enjoy signature sundaes, hand-spun milkshakes, and delectable treats in a cozy, welcoming space.
Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge Ice cream shop
Kilwins is renowned for its hand-crafted chocolates, creamy fudge, caramel apples, brittle, and super-premium ice cream, all made with the finest ingredients. Kilwins has been making people happy since 1947, providing customers with warm, friendly service and a nostalgic confectionery experience. Customers can enjoy watching fudge being paddled on a marble table and caramel cooking in a copper kettle, all in an open kitchen setting.. Kilwins is truly "Sweet in every Sense since 1947."
The Sweet Spot Ice cream shop
The Sweet Spot is a creamery Serving the best ice cream and know with our Specials "SuperShakes"
Whetstone Chocolates Chocolate shop
ince the 1970s Whetstone's name has been synonymous with delicious chocolates. The smooth taste of their delectable treats attracts locals and tourists. The Anastasia Island Whetstone Chocolate Shop offers a wide variety of treats including fudge, caramels, gelato, dessert toppings, and chocolates. Vacationers and locals can choose from their selection of white, dark, milk or even sugar-free chocolates so everyone can enjoy the taste. Whetstone's offers box gift assortments of their chocolates, personalized gifts great for any occasion, as well as individual bags of your favorite flavors.
Ben's Soft Pretzels Bakery
Ben's Pretzels are Amish-inspired and feature a fluffy, melt-in-your-mouth taste. Pair your pretzel with over 11 gourmet dipping sauces!
Tedi's Ice Cream Ice cream shop
Located on St. George Street in the heart of St. Augustine’s Historic District, Tedi’s Ice Cream is a family-run business and the oldest ice cream shop in the city. Proudly “scooping since ’66,” Tedi’s has been serving locals and visitors for generations. The shop features delicious Florida-made ice cream, fresh hand-squeezed lemonade, and waffle cones made daily. Guests can also enjoy coffee, lattes, chocolates, and a variety of sweet treats. Whether taking a break from sightseeing or cooling off on a warm Florida day, Tedi’s offers a welcoming taste of St. Augustine history.
Cinnabon Bakery
Cinnabon in St. Augustine is known for world famous cinnamon rolls, baked goods, and more. Enjoy classic cinnamon rolls in multiple sizes, delicious beverages, on-the-go treats, and take home CinnaPacks. Ideal for breakfast, dessert, or a snack, Cinnabon offers takeout, delivery, and catering for meetings, events, and celebrations. Whether you're treating yourself or sharing with a group, Cinnabon delivers irresistible flavor and indulgence in St. Augustine.
Auntie Anne's Bakery
Auntie Anne's in St. Augustine serves fresh, hot, handmade pretzels every day. Enjoy classic pretzels, cinnamon sugar pretzels, pretzel nuggets, pretzel dogs, dips, and refreshing lemonade. Perfect for families, kids, and snack lovers of all ages, Auntie Anne's is a go-to stop for sweet and savory snacks. Order in-store, for takeout, delivery, or catering for parties, events, and meetings. Whether you're grabbing a quick snack or treating the whole family, Auntie Anne's delivers warm, craveable flavor in St. Augustine.

Is this your business? Free, takes two minutes.

COAST & HOME | First Coast

© 2026 COAST & HOME | First Coast.

There’s more to Saint Augustine than you’ve discovered—and your next favorite is waiting. Coast & Home First Coast brings you tempting bites, can’t-miss events, neighborhood gems, and the stories behind our local people and businesses. Each edition opens another door to life that's close to home, with fresh finds and more reasons to get out, connect with friends, and explore what the First Coast has to offer. Subscribe so you won't miss out, and see what unfolds next.

© 2026 COAST & HOME | First Coast.