
Cookie Crush by Mayday
Sweets & Treats in St. Augustine
4.6 162 Google reviews
+1 904 792 34 2415 Hypolita St, St. Augustine, Florida 32084 · Historic District



Where to find them
15 Hypolita St, St. Augustine, Florida 32084
More of St. Augustine in your inbox
Local news, new businesses and what's on from COAST & HOME | First Coast, once a week.
About
Cookie Crush by Mayday brings warm, freshly-baked cookies together with Mayday’s handcrafted ice cream. Enjoy signature sundaes, hand-spun milkshakes, and delectable treats in a cozy, welcoming space.
Amenities
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
What people say
5 out of 5 stars
“Kate was great, friendly, helpful and gracious! Even treated my fur baby to some ice cream!”
5 out of 5 stars
“Here's a review you can post. I've written a main version plus a shorter one in case you want something quick. Main version ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Great service from Gabriel! Stopped into Cookie Crush in downtown St. Augustine and had such a great experience, thanks to Gabriel. He was friendly, welcoming, and patient while we figured out what to order, and he happily offered suggestions when we couldn't decide between all the cookie and ice cream options. Everything was fresh and delicious, and he made the whole visit feel easy and fun. You can tell he genuinely cares about making customers happy. If you're wandering around downtown looking for a sweet treat, stop in and say hi to Gabriel. Highly recommend!”
5 out of 5 stars
“We ordered cookies late at night and they tasted fresh and were absolutely delicious! The staff member who helped us was super friendly and knowledgeable. The pricing was also pretty reasonable for such a big cookie. I’d definitely stop by again next time I’m in town.”
Hours
- Wednesday
- 12 to 10 PM
- Thursday
- 12 to 10 PM
- Friday
- 12 to 11 PM
- Saturday
- 12 to 11 PM
- Sunday
- 12 to 10 PM
- Monday
- 12 to 10 PM
- Tuesday
- 12 to 10 PM
More Sweets & Treats in Saint Augustine
Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company Dessert restaurant
Indulge in velvety cheesecakes, handcrafted with exquisite precision at Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company. Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine's historic streets, this dessert haven tantalizes taste buds as a dessert restaurant, restaurant, wine store, and chocolate shop all rolled into one. With each luscious bite, savor the passion and artistry poured into every slice, paired perfectly with the right wine or a delightful hot chocolate. Whether you're seeking an intimate dinner, a sweet treat, or just a glass of wine, Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company promises a culinary experience that will linger in your memory forever.
The Hyppo Gourmet Ice Pops Ice cream shop
The Hyppo makes handcrafted gourmet ice pops using fresh, never-frozen fruit and thoughtfully selected, quality ingredients. Since 2010, we’ve created hundreds of unique flavor combinations, from refreshing fruit-forward favorites to unexpected pairings like Strawberry Basil and Mango Habanero. Visit one of our pop shops, find us through retailers and partners, or order online. Fresh fruit, bold flavors, and always something new to discover.
Coco’s Bakery Bakery
A bakery at 14 Avenida Menendez in St. Augustine.
Savannah Sweets Candy store
We specialize in traditional southern candy and gifts, Pralines, Chocolate Caramel Pecan Paws, Pecan candies, Divinity, Caramel Apples, Pecan Log Rolls, and a variety of Fudge flavors.
Our family-owned business began in beautiful Savannah, Georgia way back in 1981. Our homemade candies are made fresh daily using the freshest creams, butter and sugar. We specialize in pecan delicacies, traditional Southern candy and gift baskets perfect for family, friends and clients any time of year.
Locals, tourists and loyal customers around the country all agree, for quality products, superior service, and the very best in Pecan and Southern Candies, there is no better choice than Savannah Sweets. Your complete satisfaction is guaranteed. Enjoy!
Auntie Anne's Bakery
Auntie Anne's in St. Augustine serves fresh, hot, handmade pretzels every day. Enjoy classic pretzels, cinnamon sugar pretzels, pretzel nuggets, pretzel dogs, dips, and refreshing lemonade. Perfect for families, kids, and snack lovers of all ages, Auntie Anne's is a go-to stop for sweet and savory snacks. Order in-store, for takeout, delivery, or catering for parties, events, and meetings. Whether you're grabbing a quick snack or treating the whole family, Auntie Anne's delivers warm, craveable flavor in St. Augustine.
Cinnabon Bakery
Cinnabon in St. Augustine is known for world famous cinnamon rolls, baked goods, and more. Enjoy classic cinnamon rolls in multiple sizes, delicious beverages, on-the-go treats, and take home CinnaPacks. Ideal for breakfast, dessert, or a snack, Cinnabon offers takeout, delivery, and catering for meetings, events, and celebrations. Whether you're treating yourself or sharing with a group, Cinnabon delivers irresistible flavor and indulgence in St. Augustine.
Mayday Handcrafted Ice Cream Ice cream shop
Mayday Ice Cream is your small-batch, artisan ice cream destination in Florida. We handcraft innovative and authentic flavors, bake our own waffle cones, and hand make our own sprinkles. We are spreading joy from St. Augustine to Jacksonville, Tampa, and beyond. Online pints ship anywhere in the continental U.S., and we offer fun seasonal treats, catering, and in-store events!
Passport Sweets Candy store
International candy store, specializing in imported candy from Asia, Europe, and Latin American. Located Inside the Spanish Plaza.
Browse all sweets & treats
Run a business here? Get featured here
Is this your business? Free, takes two minutes.